Joe Jonas has some very famous exes.

We all know Jonas dated Gigi Hadid, because they just broke up last year.

Do you remember the relationship between Jonas and Demi Lovato?

How about the fact that Joe inspired Taylor Swift’s first breakup songs?

Yes it’s hard to imagine now, but there was a time when the Jonas Brothers were the absolute shiznit.

And Joe took full advantage by tossing his purity ring and gettin’ it on with some of the biggest female stars of the aughts.

But how does he feel about his all those famous exes these days?

Well, we got to find out when Andy Cohen subjected JoJo to a round of Plead the Fifth on last night’s Watch What Happens Live.

Jonas was surprisingly game to play Shag, Marry, Kill with three of his famous exes, but he seemed to struggle with answers.

The first one was easy:

“I’ll marry Demi,” Joe said. “She’s a friend.”

From there, it got a little tougher.

“Um, Shag Taylor, kill Dem—kill Gigi. There you go.” 

Jonas went on to shrug off his relationship with Taylor, saying, “We were children.”

Based on her song lyrics, we’re guessing she hasn’t been as quick to forget about it.